Know My Rights

KMR-liberty

Welcome to KnowMyRights.org!

donatenow_red

Know My Rights is a community-based non-profit organization.
Our mission is to promote social change through civil rights and other legal education.

I know my rights... Do you know yours?

U.S. Supreme Court Protects 4th Amendment Rights Of Automobile Passengers PDF Print E-mail
Written by Tim Cone, U.S.S.C.   
Monday, 18 June 2007 12:57

The defendant was a passenger in a vehicle that had been pulled over without reason to believe that it was being operated unlawfully, that is, without probable cause or reasonable suspicion to make the stop. A search of the defendant revealed his possession of drug paraphernalia. The defendant moved to suppress, but the California Supreme Court held that suppression was unwarranted because no additional circumstances indicated to a reasonable passenger that he was the subject of the police investigation.

Reversing, the Supreme Court noted that the relevant inquiry was whether a reasonable person would feel free to terminate the encounter. Here, Brendlin would not have felt free to terminate the encounter, because any reasonable passenger would have understood the officers to be exercising control to the point where no one in the car was free to depart without police permission. The Supreme Court rejected the reasoning that the police only intended to investigate the driver of the vehicle, not the passenger, noting that for Fourth Amendment analysis, subjective intent of the police is irrelevant; the relevant objective inquiry was the understanding of a reasonable passenger.




Share this with the world:
Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Google! Yahoo! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! Newsvine!

Comments

Name *
Email (For verification & Replies)
Code   
ChronoComments by Joomla Professional Solutions
Submit Comment
 

Got 'Free-Dumb'?

KMR's FREE Newsletter!

What are we doing?

The 4th Amendment Podcast

Are you in the know?....

Do you have photos of you partying posted on Facebook/MySpace?